Panerai Luminor Marina SL Boutique PAM 419

Par Florian Matrion, le 3 février 2011
Luminor Marina SL Boutique PAM 419
Luminor Marina SL Boutique PAM 419
Diaporama
The new limited "shop" edition of Panerai was very controversial when it was first introduced... Is it a commercial piece or a collector's item? TWO has conducted an exclusive investigation for you!
Exclusive! review of the Luminor Marina SL Boutique PAM 419. Manufacturer data, photos, editor's opinion and watch retail price on thewatchobserver.co.uk
L'avis de la rédaction
73/100
Note des internautes
77/100

Slideshow= 15 photos to see this watch from every angle

Please Note: The PAM 419 reviewed in this Test is only sold in Switzerland, in Geneva's Panerai store. This is why its retail price is in Swiss Francs.

 

Foreword

When its release was first announced in August of 2010, the new Luminor Marina "Special Shop Edition" triggered a lot of passionate reactions from the brand's fans and enthusiasts, a great example being the 25-page inflamed discussion from our French friends at paneristi.fr!

Indeed, Panerai has released multiple limited series all through 2010: the PAM 358 Chronopassion, PAM 357 Dubail, PAM 366 Fu, PAM 360 Ten Years of Paneristi.com, etc.
Some simply saw these additional limited series as a cheap means to increase sales...and a watering down of the "exclusive" image of the brand.

 

A Limited "Shop" Series

The "shop" Luminor Marina is only available in Panerai stores (not to be confused with the brand's retailers).
Each store has its own serial reference and its own number of copies, from 50 to 150: PAM 419 for Geneva (reviewed in this Test), PAM 414 for Paris, etc.

This represents a total number of about 1,000 copies distributed amongst 10 stores around the world: Florence, Genève, Madrid, Paris, New York, Beverly Hills, Hong Kong, Tokyo, Shanghai et Taipei.

 

The dial of this PAM 419 is packed with details reminiscent of the Pré Vendome models!

Main characteristics

All the references are identical with the exception of the engraving at the back of the case, which is country-specific: The Eiffel Tower for the Paris store, fountain for Geneva, etc.

The watch itself retains the main characteristics of the Luminor Logo 05: the case has the "bettarini" 44 mm design (using the name of the engineer who designed it in the 90's), and the movement is the classic OP II caliber.

Based on an ETA Unitas caliber and certified by the C.O.S.C., the OP II differentiates itself from the OP XI movement - which we can found on the Panerai with a sapphire back - with a simplified ornamentation using a standard carving on the bridges and the absence of a swan neck.

 

The OP XI on the other hand has a specific carving which makes it look like a vintage Panerai Corteberg movement.

While this movement is not of the greatest interest from a watchmaking point of view, its simplicity and large diameter (16.5 lines, or slightly more than 35 mm), give it a sense of sturdiness and infallible reliability...exactly what one would expect from a Panerai!

 

A Great Vintage Dial

The unique characteristics of this shop series can mostly be found with the dial which is packed with details reminiscent of the Pré Vendome models (models dating prior to the purchase of Panerai by the Richemont Group in 1998, holy grail of any collecting enthusiast of the Firenze brand which today go for astronomical prices).

The hands and markers have a beige color reminiscent of polished tritium.
This gives the watch a rather pleasing "vintage" look without becoming a caricature.

 

All the references are identical with the exception of the engraving at the back of the case, which is country-specific: The Eiffel Tower for the Paris store, fountain for Geneva, etc.

The font for the numbers is different than those of the 05 model. Its flatter appearance is also reminiscent of those used on the Pré Vendome models.
The stick markers are also thinner than the ones on the series' models.

Another characteristic is the relief Maiale replacing the logo on the dial, with the two combat divers from the 40's straddled over it.
To be more exact, the Maiale is a Siluto Lente Corsa  - or SLC, a type of piloted torpedo, which allowed Panerai's initial "customers" to infiltrate enemy harbors without detection and place explosives on the hull of docked ships.
Very few of the modern Panerai watches have this Maiale on their dial.
These sought-after details make it a real bonus for collectors.

 

Last, but important detail - though a bit subtle!
The hands are also shaped in the Pré Vendome style: the reflecting material goes all the way up to the tip of the hand, while it stops short of it on the series models.
This "shop" series is to this day the only modern model to possess this type of hands.

 

A Versatile Watch

On your wrist, this PAM 419 has all the usual charm of a Panerai: exceptional legibility and a sturdiness that make it a great multipurpose watch.

Its 44mm diameter is within today's norm, and its overall size doesn't appear at all excessive - especially with its very reasonable thickness.

The watch is very comfortable to wear with its rubber wristband, ideal for the summertime.

The Maiale, which can look very dominating in its presence on photographs, is actually very discreet once the watch is put on: it is practically invisible most of the time and doesn't overwhelm the dial.

 

Conclusions

This special Panerai "shop" series is far from being a simple marketing gadget: even if its engraved back can seem at times a little kitsch (despite its excellent production quality), it is filled with tons of original details to seduce any collector while preserving the Luminor qualities that we have come to expect.
Finally, its price, only slightly higher than the standard PAM 05 model, makes it the most affordable Panerai limited series ever made available to the public.

 

Clarifications on the Paris limited series

This limited edition will be available at the Panerai store rue de la Paix in Paris sometime in the first trimester of 2011.
It will have the PAM 414 serial reference, a limited production of 100, and a retail price of 3,800 Euros.
It will be sold simultaneously with another limited series, the Luminor 1950 10 Days GMT, referenced as PAM 404, with a production of 20, and sold at a retail price of 11,900 Euros.

 

The +:

  • collector-level details
  • excellent legibility
  • a reasonable price for a Panerai Limited Series

 

The -:

  • the slightly kitsch engraving on the back of the case

 

Additional information:

  • tester's wrist size: 17.5 cm
Diaporama
15 Photos pour voir cette montre sous toutes les coutures
Cliquez sur une Photo pour ouvrir le diaporama.
  • Luminor Marina SL Boutique PAM 419
  • Luminor Marina SL Boutique PAM 419
  • Luminor Marina SL Boutique PAM 419
  • Luminor Marina SL Boutique PAM 419
  • Luminor Marina SL Boutique PAM 419
  • Luminor Marina SL Boutique PAM 419
  • Luminor Marina SL Boutique PAM 419
  • Luminor Marina SL Boutique PAM 419
  • Luminor Marina SL Boutique PAM 419
  • Luminor Marina SL Boutique PAM 419
  • Luminor Marina SL Boutique PAM 419
  • Luminor Marina SL Boutique PAM 419
  • Luminor Marina SL Boutique PAM 419
  • Luminor Marina SL Boutique PAM 419
  • Luminor Marina SL Boutique PAM 419

Données constructeur

Marque
Modèle
Référence constructeur
Boîtier (matière)
Diamètre boîtier (hors couronne)
Diamètre boîtier (avec couronne)
Mouvement
Calibre
Base calibre
Fonctions
Verre
Capacité de la réserve de marche
Fond transparent
Entre-cornes
Longueur corne à corne
Hauteur boîtier
Etanchéité
Bracelet (matière)
Boucle (type)
Boucle (matière)
Poids total

L'avis de la rédaction 73/100

Confort / Agrément (/15)
détail Mouvement (/20)
Optimisation / Décoration du mouvement (/5) 0
Agrément de manipulation et de réglage (/5) 0
Contrôle du mouvement par la Manufacture / distinctions diverses (/3) 0
Capacité de la réserve de marche (/2) 0
Complications (/5) 0
détail Finitions (/20)
Finitions cadran (/6) 0
Finitions boîtier (/6) 0
Qualité du travail de déco° / gravure du fond de boîte (/2) 0
Qualité du verre (/4) 0
Finitions de la boucle (interne et externe) (/2) 0
détail Fonctionnalité (/20)
Lisibilité diurne (/5) 0
Lisibilité nocturne (/4) 0
Etanchéité (/3) 0
Facilité de réglage et de changement du bracelet (/4) 0
Sécurité / solidité de la boucle (/4) 0
détail Bonus (/10)
Série limitée (/3) 0
Montre fournie avec plusieurs bracelets (/2) 0
Qualité de la boîte et de la sur-boîte (/1) 0
Portabilité avec manches de chemise fermées (/2) 0
Présence de "goodies" (/1) 0
Intelligibilité du booklet (/1) 0
Rapport qualité / prix (/15)
Pour quelles occasions ? Quand la porter ?

Note des internautes 77/100

Confort / Agrément (/15)
Mouvement (/20)
Finitions (/20)
Fonctionnalité (/20)
Bonus (/10)
Rapport qualité / prix (/15)
Noter cette montre